Download this article in PD F format.

American Conifer Society, 2001

The Buck Stops Here

By Richard and Susan Eyre

We planted our first crop of conifers during the drought of 1988. The following winter the deer damage was extensive. The Pinus strobus, Thuja occidentalis and Picea abies ‘Cupressina’ were the hardest hit. We think they used the Pinus sylvestris as breath mints. Chub Harper observed the devastation and urged us to try a single strand wire electric fence for our second winter.

Our system is a low cost electric deer fence consisting of 4’ steel posts (15’ apart) connected by a wire charged with pulses of high voltage at very low current. The wire is baited with peanut butter on aluminum paddles hung along the wire. Deer love peanut butter and after they take one lick-the buck stops here! It is effective because the system is low in maintenance, low in cost and removable during the summer months. The fence is low and pets can move freely underneath. With appropriate gates installed along the walking path, humans have little risk of a shocking experience. Since we instituted the electric deer fence, deer damage has been reduced 95%.

It is important to check the fence for effectiveness and keep baiting the paddles with peanut butter. Also check for shorts in the wire. Downed branches from storms or heavy snowfall need to be removed to keep the fence on line. Whitetails prefer Skippy! (Just joking, generic peanut butter works well). By the way, the deer pruned Pinus sylvestris ‘Fastigiata’ have filled in quite nicely since the deer don’t chow down on a regular basis. The following list from The American Nurseryman on what the white tailed deer love the most.

Taste Tested

A list of ornamentals white-tailed deer favor most (97) and least (0) during the winter foraging activities.

SPECIES                                           RANKING          

Euonymus fortunei                                                       97

Taxus baccata                                                        84

Taxus cuspidata                                                     80

Taxus X media                                                 77

Taxus brevifolia                                             77

Thuja occidentalis                                         68

Rhododendron spp. (evergreen)                  47

Ilex crenata                                                     40

Ilex X meserveae                                           38

Viburnum carlesii                                    26

Juniperus virginiana                                            22

Rhododendron X laetevirens                            20

Pyracantha coccinea                                              18

Rhododendron maximum                                17

Rhododendron ‘Exbury Hybrids’                      17

Ligustrum spp.                                         16

Rhododendron carolinianum                           16

Malus domestica                                            14

Cotoneaster spp.                                         13

Euonymus alata                                        10

Juniperus chinensis                                             09

Elaeagnus angustifolia                             08

Acer palmatum                                            07

Rhododendron spp. (deciduous)                 07

Enkianthus campanulatus                          07

Tsuga canadensis                                          06

Pinus nigra                                                     06

Ilex glabra                                                       05

Prunus serrulata                                             05

Betula papyrifera                                           04

Tsuga caroliniana                                          03

Chamaecyparis pisifera                                 03

Philadelphus spp.                                         03

Viburnum tomentosum                             02

Magnolia spp.                                                 02

Ilex cornuta                                                     02

Spiraea spp.                                                    02

Betula Pendula                                                01

Leucothoe fontanesiana                            01

Kalmia latifolia                                                01

Rhododendron spp. (evergreen hybrid) 01

Syringa vulgaris                                               01

Pinus strobus                                                  01

Cornus sericea                                     01

Picea pungens                                                 01

Pieris japonica                                                01

Amelanchier spp.                                           0

Forsynthia spp.                                           0

Cornus kousa                                                    0

Pseudotsuga menziesii                                   0

Buxus sempervirens                                         0

Ilex opaca                                                          0

Abies fraseri                                                      0

Cornus florida                                                   0

Crytomeria japonica                                                0

Hisbiscus syriacus                                                 0

Picea abies                                                        0

Picea glauca                                                      0

Pinus mugo                                                       0

Pinus sylvestris                                               0

Pyrus communis                                              0